Reading the Fire:
Heat Part 3

Reading the Fire Heat Indicators briefly examined energy, temperature, and heat in thermodynamic systems, and introduced the two major categories of heat related fire behavior indicators: those that we can see (visual) and others that can be felt (tactile) as illustrated in Figure 1.

Figure 1. Basic Heat Indicator Categories

heat_indicators_5-2-2

Heat Indicators Part 2 elaborated on tactile effects. This post will examine visual effects and provide an expanded heat indicators concept map.

Remember that as with each of the B-SAHF (building, smoke, air track, heat, and flame) indicators; it is essential that assessment of heat is integrated with other elements of the B-SAHF scheme to gain a clearer sense of fire conditions and likely fire behavior.

Visual Effects

Air track often provides an early heat indicator. Observation of turbulent smoke pushing from the building at high velocity is a reliable indicator of a tremendous amount of heat energy and high temperatures inside the structure.

Figure 2. Air Track as a Heat Indicator

ranlo_c-fire_2

Note: Photo by Terry Moody, Ranlo NC.

Some visual indicators can be observed from the exterior such as bubbling paint, melting or softening roofing material, crazing glass, and condensation of pyrolyzate on windows. High temperature (and in some cases, not so high temperature) can have a more dramatic effect (see Figure 3). This vinyl frame window failed due to heat resulting from a fully developed fire inside the compartment.

Figure 3. Temperature Effects on Building Materials

temp_effects_window

Note: Photo by Ed Hartin

Fire stream effects such as evaporation of water from a hot surface (such as a door) or lack of return from a temperature check (brief application of water fog into the hot gas layer to check overhead temperature) also provide an indication of temperature (Figure 4)

Figure 4. Checking the Door and Temperature Check

door_and_temp

Note: Photo by John McDonough

A thermal imaging camera (TIC) provides a highly effective means for visualizing temperature differences (see Figure 5). Use of a TIC should begin on the exterior and continue during interior operations.

Figure 5. Thermal Image

thermal_image

Note: Photo provided by Stefan Svensson

Despite the tremendous advantage provided by use of a TIC, it is essential to be mindful of the limitations of this technology. Thermal images only identify the temperature differences that are in direct line-of-sight. Insulating materials such as compartment linings can prevent the TIC from identifying fire conditions outside the compartment (e.g., floor below, ceiling void). In tests of floor and roof assemblies conducted by the Underwriters Laboratory (UL), thermal imaging cameras were unable to detect a fully developed fire below a typical wood floor (see Figure 6). The floor in Figure 6 consisted of an engineered system of I-joists, sub-floor, finished floor, carpet padding, and carpet. The floor system was being tested over a 14′ x 17′ (4.27 m x 5.18 m) gas fired furnace in accordance with ASTM E119. While the temperature indicated by the TIC is 80.1o F (27o C), the highest temperature measured by thermocouples on the structural members was in excess of 1341o F (727o C). It is essential to integrate thermal image data with direct visual observations to obtain a more complete picture of temperature conditions.

Figure 6. UL Floor Systems Test

i-joist_quadview

Adapted from Underwriters Laboratory Structural Stability of Engineered Lumber in Fire Conditions [on-line training program]

The tests of engineered lumber systems and training program developed by UL provide excellent information on performance of these structural materials under fire conditions. This program as well as on-line training on fire behavior in single family dwellings and fire modeling are available free of charge from UL University.

Technological advancements also include temperature sensing integrated into breathing apparatus, personal alert safety systems (PASS), and even protective clothing (see Figure 7) to assist firefighters in recognizing dangerous elevated temperatures and in some cases telemetry to transmit this information to others, outside the hazardous environment. This could be viewed as a visual indicator (based on visual display of the information) or as augmentation of tactile indicators.

Figure 7. Smart Clothing by Viking Industries

viking_thermal_sensor

Work in Progress

Hopefully we have been working on this project together and you have been developing or refining the air track segment of your fire behavior indicators concept map. My current map is illustrated in Figure 8.

Figure 8. Heat Indicators Concept Map v5.2.2.1

heat_indicators_5-2-2-1

You can also download a printer friendly version of the Heat Indicators Concept Map v5.2.2.1 As always, should you have any suggestions or feedback, please post a comment!

Ed Hartin, MS, EFO, MIFireE, CFO

References

Underwriters Laboratory. (2009). Structural Stability of Engineered Lumber in Fire Conditions [on-line training program]. Retrieved August 27, 2009 from http://www.ul.com/global/eng/pages/offerings/industries/buildingmaterials/fire/courses/structural/

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!

Tags: , , , , ,



6 Responses to “Reading the Fire:
Heat Part 3”

  1. Jesse Says:

    Under tactile effects of heat in my FBI concept map I included exposed skin sensing. In a fire behavior class I took a few years ago, I learned that humans will automatically retract their hand if the back of the hand is exposed to 400 degrees F. I can combine this with the knowledge that one indicator of impending flashover is 500 degrees F at mid-wall (assuming 8ft ceilings). Of course, this is my own map and I’m not saying it’s OK for another firefighter to pull back a glove and expose their skin, especially if it goes against department SOP’s.
    Some visual head indicators I use is the “life of a window.” Is there condensation on the window? If so, the temp in the room is under 212 F. Is it heat stained and no condensation is visible? Is the window cracked (crazed)? Or is it completely broken/blown out? I’ve been told that a window will fail at 600 F (can’t remember the length of exposure). Can you confirm or clarify this, Ed? I seem to recall an earlier post on window failure.

  2. Jesse Says:

    oops: “visual heat indicators”

  3. hartin Says:

    Jesse, I would caution against using skin as a thermometer! Burn injuries result from the skin absorbing energy resulting from radiant and/or convective heat transfer. Relatively small fires in an enclosed area present a significant burn hazard to exposed skin. Thanks for you comment as it has motivated me to develop several posts dealing with the thermal environment in compartment fires, burn injuries, and the like.

    On you second point, this is also more complicated that window failure at a single temperature. This depends on the glass, temperature differential between interior and exterior, temperature differences between the center and edges of the window, number of panes (e.g., double or triple pane), etc. It is reasonable to assume that if you see condensation of water (rather than pyrolizate) the fire is in its incipient or early growth stage (with limited increased in temperature above ambient). Condensed pyrolizate will accumulate on the windows as smoke production increases in the growth stage (with a corresponding increase in interior temperature).

    Underwriters Laboratory recently received a grant to investigate ventilation controlled fires in legacy and new construction and they will be looking at window performance among other things.

    Cheers,
    Ed

  4. Blog Archive » Battle Drill Part 2 | Compartment Fire Behavior Says:

    […] Heat Indicators Part 3 […]

  5. Blog Archive » Gas Cooling: Part 4 | Compartment Fire Behavior Says:

    […] Heat Indicators Part 3 […]

  6. Blog Archive » Influence of Ventilation in Residential Structures: Tactical Implications Part 3 | Compartment Fire Behavior Says:

    […] Part 2 Air Track Indicators Air Track Indicators Part 2 Heat Indicators Heat Indicators Part 2 Heat Indicators Part 3 Flame Indicators Flame Indicators Part 2 Incipient Stage Fires: Key Fire Behavior Indicators Growth […]

Leave a Reply